I just thought I’d get this out of the way early. Here’s a question for you: Why, oh why, don’t we – in general – care about soccer in Canada?
Sure, the world is awash in World Cup fever. Even some of us north of the 49th are taking an active interest in the tournament. Of course, I’ve seen this movie before – and I know how it ends:
- The general public doesn’t give a wet slap about professional soccer (wash, rinse, repeat for three years;
- The World Cup draw happens. Suddenly everyone’s an expert. Debates about which Group forms the dreaded Group of Death get heated;
- World Cup matches start;
- Fan interest spikes beyond the traditional ethnic communities that form the basis of Canadian soccer viewership during the World Cup;
- Pundits work themselves in a lather saying that now, finally, for real this time, we really mean it, honestly, this is not like any other time, this time it’s a sure thing that North Americans have embraced soccer!;
- World Cup ends, euphoria subsides;
- Canadians go back to not caring about soccer… until the next World Cup; and
- *** Special Bonus Plan *** Pundits get to work themselves into another lather, gobbling up inches upon inches of print space (or pixels upon pixels of screen space…) investigating why another opportunity was lost to convert North American sports fans into soccer fans.
So, knowing where we’re going to be in a few weeks anyways, I thought I’d jump the gun and look at what it is about North America that prevents us from embracing soccer at its elite level. And it’s an issue of importance to us here at Amway Canada, as we’re heavily involved in the sport from a corporate perspective, including being title sponsor of the Nutrilite Canadian Championship – a tournament that pits Canada’s top professional clubs against each other for the Voyageurs Cup and the right to represent our nation as part of the FIFA Club World Cup tournament. *** Warning, sweeping generalisations may appear. Arguments based on feelings, not facts may be present***
Let me start by saying I know it’s football. Footy, the Beautiful Game. I get it. But to me football is played with three downs and rewards failure thanks to something called the rouge! Oh, and there’s also that U.S. version which is pretty good too! Four downs to get 10 yards, though… amateurs.
Oh, and by the way, I just found out that soccer is actually a British term!!!! Used first in the 1880s as an abbreviation of asSOCiation football*! So there. Stop being snobs. *reference taken from Wikipedia and we all know the Internet doesn’t lie, so it’s got to be true, right?
North Americans in general are sports fans. And thanks to the 24-hour, non-stop news cycle (and about a gazillion specialty channels) we have access to every sport imaginable. Of course, you’ve got the big guns: hockey, Canadian and American football, baseball, and basketball. You have your curling, golf, and tennis fans out there. Figure skating’s extremely popular (again, we have a vested interest through our ARTISTRY® Skate Canada sponsorship.) And NASCAR and F1 fans are very vocal in support of their sport.
In fact, if you tune into TSN, SportsNet, ESPN, or any other sports network during the wee hours of the morning, you’ll see that our appetite for televised competition is almost insatiable. We’ll broadcast lumberjack challenges, poker, competitive eating, and dog shows for Pete’s sake! The appetite for sports is there, but for some reason soccer just doesn’t sate it on this continent.
The thing is a lot of us put our kids in soccer. According to FIFA’s Big Count, using statistics from 2006, almost 2.7 million Canadians played the sport. Compared to hockey, it’s cheap to get involved, it’s fun, and kids can pick up the sport pretty quickly. But they’re not taking that next leap. They’re not idolizing the heroes of the pitch. They’re not wearing their Everton or Real Madrid jerseys to school, like they would their Habs jersey or Jays’ ball cap.
So what’s the problem? The world loves soccer, why don’t we share the same depth of passion?
One thought is that we’re a nation (I’m speaking for Canada here, but I think the same applies south of the border) that’s grown up on sports that offer instant gratification. Hockey, basketball, football – even baseball’s regularly fast-paced. There’s almost always a payoff – and even when there isn’t, we massage the rules to ensure that one exists (see the addition of the shootout to hockey). Baseball has a pitcher/batter dynamic at each and every at bat. Basketball games feature non-stop scoring and defence is sometimes an afterthought. Football offers controlled violence and while scoring is not as plentiful as it is in basketball, there are small victories and gains throughout the game. Hockey is a game of chances – in fact, there are so many that we often further break down shots on goal into quality chances. We like our games completed in well under three hours and sprinkled with plenty of offence.
Soccer? Not so much. To the casual observer, it can seem interminable. While advocates will laud the beauty of a nil-nil match, Joe Fan laments the fact that it just seems like the players are running around relatively aimlessly, to the point where even at shot at the goal (a rare occurrence at the top levels) is celebrated enthusiastically.
Of course, when you consider other popular sports in those regions, you can understand. Take cricket, for example. A test can last, what, six weeks? Soccer, despite its languorous pace would seem positively ADHD-esque in comparison.
The argument that really rubs my rhubarb the wrong way is that North American sports fans can’t appreciate the nuances of a well-played match. Somehow the thrill of an unsuccessful rush up the wing is lost, or that the appreciation for the systems employed is just not there.
Listen, there are smart fans on both sides of the border. There are those who appreciate the game within the game. But let’s be honest here: Liam, William, and Eleanor, sitting at the pub, pounding Guinness, aren’t dissecting the merits of a 4-4-2 formation over adopting a 4-3-3 triangular midfield, just as Frank, Kristin, and Bobby aren’t discussing whether their favourite team should employ the left-wing lock, defend with a box-and-one, or have the left guard pull on the next run. In general, fans want to be entertained and prefer superlative play to systems analysis (see the vehement hatred for the neutral-zone-trap and prevent defence).
The modern sport of soccer as we know it was officially born in 1863, when the Laws of the Game were put in place. Now, I know dozens of places can (and will) lay claim to being the birthplace of the sport – kind of like the ‘where did hockey start?’ debate here in Canada (my money’s still on McGill…), but that’s a discussion for another place. Since 1886, the International Football Association Board has governed the rules of play at the international level. That’s good enough for me.
But the game is far older than the official date. There are reports of soccer-esque games being played hundreds of years ago in China, Scotland in the Middle Ages, South America and other locales. Have ball, kick ball, score is a pretty basic concept, so it’s not a surprise that versions of the game sprouted up worldwide.
There’s a history and that’s certainly a significant factor. Whilst fans in Liverpool can look back fondly on over 150 years of history, the team in Canada that’s enjoyed the greatest popular success in soccer, Toronto FC, was only founded in 2006. Sport allows people from all walks of life to come together for a common cause – but while this breadth of support is important, it’s the depth of support that forms the strongest bonds. In Canada, fans of the Montreal Canadiens can share memories with their parents, grandparents, and great grandparents. Oftentimes, fandom isn’t a choice, but rather a birthright.
What about hero worship? Although the sports adage is that you play for the logo on the front of your jersey, not the name on the back, the fact remains that people – kids especially – attach themselves to a particular player. In my day it was Guy Lafleur, Wayne Gretzky, and Marcel Dionne. Nowadays, Canadian kids are looking up to Sidney Crosby, Alexander Ovechkin, LeBron James, and Peyton Manning. The MLSers who populate the rosters are often nearing the end of their playing days (see David Beckham) or not at the elite level required to play overseas.
It’s easy to picture yourself filling Sid the Kid’s skates, because many of us share a similar background. Soccer? Well, players with names like Kaka simply send kids into fits of giggles, whilst the greats of the game like Lionel Messi, Drogba, and Christian Ronaldo toil overseas (and in early Sunday-morning games). Maybe that’s going to turn around with the success of homegrown players like Dwayne de Rosario and Julian de Guzman for the hometown Toronto FC squad. And that’s why a tournament like the Nutrilite Canadian Championship is so important and holds so much potential for growth.
There are a lot of things that soccer does right – first and foremost is the game’s respect for fans and its ability to create an atmosphere. In terms of pandering to the fans, NBA games are the worst – but hockey and football are a close second and third. The jumbotron constantly flashes directions to the crowd “Go Team Go” or those stupid gloved hands. And don’t even get me started on Cotton-Eyed Joe… There should be a fatwa declared on any and all PA announcers that play that song – anywhere. Any break in play has to be filled by noise, perky cheerleaders (or dance teams), or dusting off the YMCA! It’s like the overlords of North American sport refuse to believe that fans can enjoy (or need) the pauses that come during games and that if they’re not overwhelmed by a wall of noise and light, they’ll accidentally wander out of their seats towards the exits.
Conversely, in soccer the fans are the spectacle. They create wonderful chants that the whole crowd gets involved with (of course, they’ve got plenty of time – not being encumbered by, oh, goals, or anything). Sure, some of them go a little overboard (the football factories and hooligans being the prime culprits), but for the most part the game is made by its atmosphere.
Truly, there’s nothing better than being there. I want to be a soccer fan, but I’m really not. That said, every time I’ve gone to BMO Field for a Toronto FC game, the atmosphere lasts with me far longer than the final score. For a taste, check out the Nutrilite Canadian Soccer Facebook page for videos and photos from the recent tournament – you’ll see what I mean.
There’s always hope that things will change. With homegrown talents like the aforementioned de Rosario and de Guzman, and an elite player like Landon Donovan south of the border, we’re starting to see North Americans excel at the international level. Maybe that will translate into greater home-grown interest. But while that alleviates one of the symptoms, it fails to address the fundamental issues North American fans have with the game.
In my mind, the game doesn’t need to change. Either we need to change our perceptions to appreciate it more, or we accept that soccer here will be like the NHL in the States – a regionally relevant sport that just can’t attain mass appeal except for major events like the World Cup. After all, it works for tennis (viewership increases for grand slams) and golf (same for the majors).
In the end, there’s really nothing wrong with that.