There was an article in today's paper discussing the challenges that some of our local students are having passing the Grade 10 literacy test -- again. I have to say, sadly, knowing what I know of our educational system and seeing what I see in day-to-day life, I'm not surprised.
You can read the article here. But I'll give you the synopsis. The good? About 80 per cent of students pass it on the first try. The bad news? Almost half of the students who failed it the first time around, fail it again when they retake it as senior high school students.
View a sample of th is year's test yourself here. Go ahead, I'll wait.
Pretty easy, right? Should be a snap. Well, that may be the case for those of us who learned grammar in school, but it would be a heck of a challenge for kids who have only been exposed to these concepts by osmosis! And that appears to be the situation facing our students.
My son, in his first year of high school, is getting smacked in the face by both Strunk and White (although he probably won't get that reference). His marks are suffering in English due to the fact that his writing abilities are not up to snuff. I've tried to help, but you know how teenagers are about their parents' understanding of 'modern education'...
The biggest issue facing our kids? Grammar is an afterthought.
This isn't a new situation -- it's one that's been developing for years, and one in which we've tried to solicit his teachers' help. He's frequently penned pieces that are almost illegible: sentences don't finish, verb tenses come and go as he pleases, spelling -- well, we won't get into it. Yet, despite all of this, he's consistently received A's for his efforts.
Incredulous, my wife and I have approached his teachers, saying, "How can this be an A? It's riddled with errors and it's incomplete in places!" The answer? Let me introduce the bane of any English lover's existence.
Reading comprehension.
Yes, the answer we received from one of his teachers was, "Well, I could figure out what he was trying to say, so that's good enough." Really???? Good enough?
You see, it's not important any more for our kids to be able to craft a sentence -- to frame a thought with words, written with a specific intent in mind. No, as long as they "get it," that's good enough. Who cares why there's a period at the end of the sentence, or if the kid can't understand every fifth word -- as long as he gets the general idea of the story, he's good to go.
But this isn't a new problem. I never learned grammar in English throughout my schooling. I was in one of those 'gifted' programs, which apparently enabled me the right to be a free-ranged educational chicken, walking through the scholastic barnyard pecking at those things which would stimulate my interest. My math and grammar education? Cards and sheets handed to us once a week.
High school, university? No better. Again, the focus was on reading comprehension. Understanding the intent, without appreciating the craft. (Admittedly, a university poetry course did get into the technical stuff -- but I rarely write in iambic pentameter any more....)
No, the only places I learned English grammar were: five years of Latin; French classes; and self-teaching as I worked through the newspaper ranks. If I had not taken an active interest in bettering my skills, I would never have been exposed to the opportunity to do so. And that's completely wrong.
So we're willing to take this attitude with the English language: as long as they get it, they don't need to understand how it's done. I wonder if we'd be willing to take such liberties with other disciplines. For example, would you be comfortable going to a doctor who could identify your disease, but would have no understanding of how it interacts with your body, how it progresses, or what causes it to manifest?
Probably not. We call doctors who hack and slash their way through their patients butchers... but that's exactly what we're allowing people to do to the English language.
We've always placed a premium on reading and language in our home. I've been writing for about two decades now, and speak English and French. My wife speaks four languages and has travelled the world. We appreciate the importance of language and communication in expressing yourself and understanding the world around us.
So why are robbing our children of that same ideal? Yes, learning grammar can be long and tedious. But be honest -- when you read a letter from a compay or see a sign for a business riddled with spelling errors, doesn't that change your perception of them? Would you hire someone who came to you with a cover letter and resume that had sentences which didn't finish, or had the wrong they're/their/theres or which/witches?
Of course you would. But where's the answer? How tough is it, when you're trying to teach your kid the consequences to handing in poor work, to have your beliefs nullified by an A+ from a teacher who graded the class based upon understanding the general idea of what they were doing? Unfortunately, we've become credible at the wrong time for our son. He laughed off our concerns in elementary school, but now that he has a teacher who demands a little more, things are changing.
In the end, English is the foundation for everything in our society. A mastery of reading and writing opens up a world of other opportunities. Sure science and art may be opposites at times, but if you can't read, how are you going to use that biology textbook? Does it not go without saying that the better you read, the more you'll understand, and the greater your ability will be to express your thoughts?
Maybe it's just me. Again, maybe I'm living in a world that doesn't exist -- and didn't even when I was going to school. But as much as I appreciate my ability to 'get' Robertson Davies' works, if he didn't understand how to write in the first place, wouldn't it all be for naught in the end?
Tell me what you think and what your experiences are with the English language. Did you learn grammar in school? How do you react when presented with misspellings, errors, and poor writing? How much do you value good writing? I'd love to hear from you.
All the best,
Jay